What if Anakin DIDN'T Burn? FULL - Star Wars Theory Fan-Fic

In today's Star Wars fan-fic, let's dive into the what if scenario if Anakin Skywalker didn't burn on Mustafar. He still lost to Obi-Wan Kenobi as in Revenge of the Sith, but he didn't burn, which resulted in most of his injuries and loss of powers.
Would he find Luke and Leia? Would he fight Yoda and Obi-Wan? Would he overthrow Sidious? What becomes of the chosen one? How powerful would Anakin be, now?
How does this impact the fate of the Star Wars timeline?

NEW SPOTIFY podcast is now live - type Star Wars Theory into search

Continue the conversation on the Theory forums!

Become a Patron to support future content - www.patreon.com/StarWarsTheory

Join this channel to get access to perks:


  1. caleb cook

    caleb cook

    2 orë më parë

    The best part in any star wars story is Anakin admiring his daughters nose

  2. Laurence Lafferty

    Laurence Lafferty

    3 orë më parë

    What if Vader sensed the Force in Leah when he faced off with her on the supply ship?

  3. TheGlitchedHack


    3 orë më parë

    *What if : What if there was a way to delete the sequel trilogy*

  4. Ilja Sidlun

    Ilja Sidlun

    4 orë më parë

    But wasn't old Obi Wan strong enough to kill Vader in ANH, but saw Luke redeeming him instead?

  5. Mario Dantonio

    Mario Dantonio

    5 orë më parë

    What if I won the lottery and Anakin didn't burn? I would be rich and dear sweet Ani would have his angelic looks now givin to him by the metachlorins that inpregnated Shimi.That be awesome, but neither of those things are real, sadly .But this was still a fun video, cheers!*The Vader books and comics are good reads.Somethimg he's dead wife would of said, did you take out the trash and pick up the kids from the birthday party?

  6. NythanJediMills


    5 orë më parë

    a what if on Legacy of the Force: Invincible, would be appreciated

  7. FidoTheClown


    6 orë më parë

    WOW! Just wow!

  8. Inanimate Carbon Rod

    Inanimate Carbon Rod

    6 orë më parë

    Anakin's turn back to the light in this is definitely solid. his entire nature was being fractured and fragile and it always came out in his most stressful moments.

  9. Bailey Green

    Bailey Green

    6 orë më parë

    I read the title ‘turn’ not ‘burn’ 😂

  10. james jones

    james jones

    7 orë më parë

    Lord Vader was also hindered by the suit that sidious had made to weaken him.

  11. TheBrendon67


    8 orë më parë

    “…and when he kills yoda”… I like how you just sort of threw that out there so nonchalantly. Perfect!

  12. firex


    8 orë më parë

    Hell, I don't know why, but I burst into tears from the ending. Plus I would be interested to see if Anakin reached the maximum in his power. But the ending is of course very powerful. I really cried.

  13. John Craig

    John Craig

    10 orë më parë

    What if anakin didn't lose his arm to dooku.

  14. John Craig

    John Craig

    10 orë më parë

    But Yoda said. "Luminous beings are we." "Not this crude matter ". Referring the human flesh. So how does that diminish ones force ability?

  15. Taylor A. Auzins

    Taylor A. Auzins

    10 orë më parë

    Well done!

  16. Jesse Garcia

    Jesse Garcia

    11 orë më parë

    The thumbnail made me picture anikan came from a fat sesh when he was on his way to the chancellor from the umbara offense and trying to play it off cool and ready to serve n shit

  17. Christopher Tryhorn

    Christopher Tryhorn

    11 orë më parë

    This this right here needs to be a movie series Anakin becoming stronger then emperor and killing him. Anakin training Luke all of it I’d watch these movies

  18. Steven Saldivar

    Steven Saldivar

    16 orë më parë

    Do you think Anakin's ability to see the future was something he could use in combat?

  19. JDOGG.23GC Tha Tiny LoC

    JDOGG.23GC Tha Tiny LoC

    18 orë më parë

    Please do "what if windu deuled Anakin" and have Mace Windu kill Palpatine afterwards then as kenobi goes to fight sepratist council w Ashoka and 332nd, Windu and Yoda cover up anakins betrayal and say he was killed with the other Jedi before Windu fell into Vapaad and changed history w an amethyst blade , so have padme still die of a broken heart after finding out truth ( w leia like sleuthing) and Luke and Leia are Trained by Windu to use their inner darkness and schooled in vapaad w purple bladed lightsabers of their own as yoda and old ben trains them force ghosts and the greater mysteries, have them find out about the truth finding a copy of footage their mom found along w sidious pair of lightsabers both adding a red blade to their purple and becoming dark jedi who find exegol and tru sith leading first order w kylo Ren and Ren w knights and inquisitors to face the jedi ( fill in blanx)

  20. Ray Jones

    Ray Jones

    18 orë më parë

    Bravo my friend. Well done

  21. Cyberpsychosis


    21 orë më parë

    All the really weird bots in this comment section... yikes.

  22. Tony Stark`

    Tony Stark`

    21 orë më parë

    11:58 to 12:07 They could've spared those Stormtroopers and squeezed them in too :( Those troopers never did anything to anyone, they were too slow. ;-;

  23. Obi-Wan Kenobi

    Obi-Wan Kenobi

    Ditë më parë

    Darth Malgus used force lightning and he was cybernetic

  24. Mr gamer

    Mr gamer

    Ditë më parë

    Why can’t they just clone Leah

  25. Conviction


    Ditë më parë

    I really don't think Anikin would just stay there on the death star.

  26. Bonk


    Ditë më parë

    What if anakin was granted the rank of Master

  27. George Kaza

    George Kaza

    Ditë më parë

    I don't really understand why in this theory Anakin is made to be such an emotional killer while the reason he joined the dark side was to save his loved one's (in which case it's his daughter and son)

  28. fleetstreet11


    Ditë më parë

    God-Emperor Vader, that's what.

  29. Der Rückkehrer

    Der Rückkehrer

    Ditë më parë

    Who knew the little shit that was Annie in Episode One would grow up to be the slashing antagonist of the likes of a horror movie all the same. And he's supposed to be a good guy? No scenario makes Anakin good because he is twisted all the same.

  30. Critical Jake

    Critical Jake

    Ditë më parë

    I'm Soo glad you finally did this fanfiction it was something I always wondered, just imagine if Disney+ does a "what if " series for star wars.

  31. Eli Skywalker

    Eli Skywalker

    Ditë më parë

    You are the reason I'm a star wars fan

  32. Eli Skywalker

    Eli Skywalker

    Ditë më parë

    Love your vids

  33. Anbu


    2 ditë më parë

    Anakin probably would have been the most powerful sith to ever live

  34. Ewan


    2 ditë më parë

    I think you've neglected one factor. Vader is in tremendous pain from the suit. Which he uses to fuel his anger to gain strength. Without the painful armour, and with the loss of limbs, I think he'd be weaker than the Vader we know

  35. Izziwizzi Woof

    Izziwizzi Woof

    2 ditë më parë

    Anakin wouldn’t of died because he has cloned himself

  36. Violet Sobieski

    Violet Sobieski

    2 ditë më parë

    Now that Star Wars has time travel (how cranky Palp's lived on in the silly Disney movies and the Vale of the Force) why doesn't Old Palpy go back and sort out Obi Wan with Anakin to get his prized apprentice or even help out cranky Mauly boy with Qui Gon and Obi Wan so that they both get Anakin at an earlier age?? See how silly Disney sh*t can just ruin everything!! Those poor lightsaber crystals will be crying and bleeding if old Palpy went back in time and ensure they came out on top way earlier hey!!

  37. Jerry Kompier

    Jerry Kompier

    2 ditë më parë

    this was a good one!

  38. Pulsedown


    2 ditë më parë

    Man this was a master piece i‘m so happy that you do all the Videos and help me to go through depression. Your videos are a light for me to keep on, that’s be said. Much love for you 💙 may the Force be with you.

  39. Jay Ramsey

    Jay Ramsey

    2 ditë më parë

    Mr. Theory does a dope Hayden/Anakin/Vader impression.

  40. J. R.

    J. R.

    2 ditë më parë

    This was badass to watch. Thanks man!

  41. Michael Kiese

    Michael Kiese

    2 ditë më parë

    2:30 really? Obiwan couldn’t just force push Anakin into the lava? Lol

  42. McNizzzle


    2 ditë më parë

    guess he shoulda just fought him naked. “Florida Chosen One Loses Limbs on Mustafar”

  43. Whiplasher Gaming

    Whiplasher Gaming

    2 ditë më parë

    like how marvel made MCU's What if....?, we have to get one on star wars

  44. To fast For you.

    To fast For you.

    2 ditë më parë

    Marvel what if? Naaaa . Star wars what could of been?

  45. Darth Vader

    Darth Vader

    2 ditë më parë

    If only my friend

  46. Arclight104


    3 ditë më parë

    Its hard to buy Anakin being accepted as Emperor without a Civil War after killing Palpatine. Its hard to buy Anakin as Emperor. Anakin was incredibly naive and easy to manipulate and consistantly unable to understand people at an emotional level. These are terrible traits for a politician. Sure age and experience can mitigate some of that but without being a master manipulator like Sidious he is not going to last long in the vipers nest that was the Imperial senate. He either falls to x,y,z number of assassination plots or ends up being a de facto puppet to more skilled politicians able to control him by playing on his all too obvious emotions.

  47. John Cabaniss

    John Cabaniss

    3 ditë më parë

    I like ur theory in this instance, keep up the good work. I like watching these videos u make, and i am old enough that i saw the originals at the theatre . And yes that is how theatre was originally spelled, b 4 they changed it to theater

  48. Montana Iverson

    Montana Iverson

    3 ditë më parë

    2:40 you mean the Emperor Palpatine Surgical Reconstruction Center?

  49. Lukas Schmitter

    Lukas Schmitter

    3 ditë më parë

    I‘d definitely watch a 3 hour movie version of this anytime

  50. Timbo Slice

    Timbo Slice

    3 ditë më parë

    I like how this mirrors the son being the dark the daughter being light and anakin replacing the father after all

  51. Tilted Haze

    Tilted Haze

    3 ditë më parë

    It’s awesome how much you revere Star Wars and these characters…it shows how much love you hold for the material in these stories you tell. 👍🏼

  52. Owen Greig

    Owen Greig

    3 ditë më parë

    This is what would have happened if the films were made in chronological order.

  53. Michael Espinoza

    Michael Espinoza

    3 ditë më parë

    I would love to see Disney do a What if... Star Wars

  54. JP Studios

    JP Studios

    3 ditë më parë

    Amazing story 👏🏻👏🏻

  55. Ben G

    Ben G

    3 ditë më parë

    May or may not make the most interesting fanfic, but here's an idea..."what if Maul won his last duel against Obi Wan?" Now hear me out, I believe Maul said something about Obi Wan protecting someone, so he might have guessed Luke's presence. And knowing that he didn't have control over Ezra as an apprentice, would he seek out Luke?

  56. Burauni


    3 ditë më parë

    What if vader had somehow not have been dismembered and only burnt? That'd make a cool fan fic, Imagine with all the hate and rage anakin had he'd have continued dueling with obi wan while he would've slowly burned up until his body couldn't support him and he'd just collapse.

  57. caleb duck

    caleb duck

    3 ditë më parë

    what if Anakin was not cut ?

  58. STH_ AKL

    STH_ AKL

    3 ditë më parë

    Is there anywhere to buy the full star wars book collection?

  59. Christopher james Roberts- king

    Christopher james Roberts- king

    3 ditë më parë

    What if leia becomes dark side of the force the first woman be come evil ?

  60. Anarion


    3 ditë më parë

    Not bad. I liked it. So I have always had another idea. Maybe this has already been explored but what if Luke turned to the dark side after Jedi? My idea is that the fight with Vader put a seed in his mind and during the clean-up of the Imperial remnants, that seed grew as he fought more battles. Luke, commanding a recovered star destroyer, would decide that as the last Jedi only he could bring order to the galaxy. You can see where this is going. I thought of this a long time ago...so this is not influenced by the times. If you know what I mean.

  61. Grim Reaper

    Grim Reaper

    3 ditë më parë

    As the sirens blared. Blaze would indicate that the sirens burned. Blared indicates sound.

  62. Dagorblade


    3 ditë më parë

    And then his cloned limbs start deteriorating.

    • Judy 21 y.o - check my vidéó

      Judy 21 y.o - check my vidéó

      3 ditë më parë

      “What if people had confidence in Chancellor Valorum?”

  63. Jacob Rick

    Jacob Rick

    4 ditë më parë

    I thought you said Analin didnt burn😂

  64. Peter's pythons

    Peter's pythons

    4 ditë më parë

    Disney plus have to do a what if for star wars like marvel

  65. PointBlank200


    4 ditë më parë

    he will have a pale skin and creepy wrinkles

    • •T[A]P Me!! To Have [S]EX With Me

      •T[A]P Me!! To Have [S]EX With Me

      3 ditë më parë

      I would want to see a “What If” of Anakin letting Mace kill Palpatine, and then another of Anakin never losing to Obi wan but staying with the dark side. I get the whole “his children showed him the Light”, but at the same time, seeing Anakin at his full potential, especially w the Dark side would be crazy

  66. Miguel noche

    Miguel noche

    4 ditë më parë

    Alternate title of this video: what if katheline kennedy didnt exist

  67. Joseph Collins

    Joseph Collins

    4 ditë më parë

    I would definitely love to see a visual of this!!

  68. Toni di Pianduni

    Toni di Pianduni

    4 ditë më parë

    This was amazing!

    • Go To My 𝗖𝗵𝗮𝗻nel [𝗟!𝘃𝗲Chat

      Go To My 𝗖𝗵𝗮𝗻nel [𝗟!𝘃𝗲Chat

      3 ditë më parë

      Maul got new legs, Anakin got new legs Maul: “Noticed you’ve copied my legs”

  69. Jonathan Choiniere

    Jonathan Choiniere

    4 ditë më parë

    I see what you did there in the story. Leia being light side Luke going dark being a reflection of the Son and Daughter from clone wars

  70. Torben


    4 ditë më parë

    But I thought Vader would not burn in this fanfic

    • Go To Channel [𝐋!𝐯𝐞 S.A.X]

      Go To Channel [𝐋!𝐯𝐞 S.A.X]

      3 ditë më parë

      This would be an amazing “WHAT IF…?” Star Wars episode.

  71. Leviathan


    4 ditë më parë

    The it would have turned out VERY different....sorry Luke.

  72. Andrew Bechtol

    Andrew Bechtol

    4 ditë më parë

    You should do a video on if anakin never lost any limbs including when he fought doku and never burned

    • Anne-[S]EX-Vlog Go to My Channel

      Anne-[S]EX-Vlog Go to My Channel

      3 ditë më parë

      This would be an amazing “WHAT IF…?” Star Wars episode.

  73. Cyber 9

    Cyber 9

    4 ditë më parë

    Great intro

  74. Hermione Granger

    Hermione Granger

    4 ditë më parë

    You forget... Obi-Wan has a perfectly anti-Anakin/Vader home. High-ground + sand = no Anakin/Vader.

    • Hermione Granger

      Hermione Granger

      2 ditë më parë

      @Abbie Bria His kids didn't bring balance to the force! Anakin destroyed that Sith. Sure, Luke might have helped, but I think Anakin would have come around sooner or later, anyway.

    • Abbie Bria

      Abbie Bria

      3 ditë më parë

      So if his kids brought balance it essentially means that Anakin still is the chosen one in that he brought balance to the Force by banging Padmé.

  75. Tehillahville


    4 ditë më parë

    that was a good anakin impression

    • T[A]P Me!! To Have [S]EX With Me

      T[A]P Me!! To Have [S]EX With Me

      3 ditë më parë

      If Star Wars doesn’t hop on that “what if” grind imma be mad asf .

  76. Jeremy Keitt

    Jeremy Keitt

    5 ditë më parë

    This would be an amaaaazing what if. This was just as, if not, more heart wrenching than the OT. The all powerful emperor tares apart the galaxy for the love his life only to realize that love was right in front of him all along. Bravo.

  77. Nick Sikes

    Nick Sikes

    5 ditë më parë

    I received that book and I smashed it fast before seeing the movie. It was still awesome in both cases.

    • Tammy 23 y.o - check my vidéó

      Tammy 23 y.o - check my vidéó

      3 ditë më parë

      In short, Anakin would basically become a demi god.

  78. Slowbro


    5 ditë më parë

    What if the Anakin's clone gunship on geonosis wasn't out of rockets? What if they killed Dooku before he could escape and deliver the death star plans?

  79. Aksel Lien

    Aksel Lien

    5 ditë më parë

    Reminded of Netflix Castlevania

  80. Andrew Gordon

    Andrew Gordon

    5 ditë më parë

    I love it! great thought!

  81. Tyler Slagel

    Tyler Slagel

    5 ditë më parë

    Vaderkin wouldn’t have kept the Death Star as he saw it as useless. And without Palpatine, he wouldn’t be forced to safeguard it either.

  82. Suck your mum

    Suck your mum

    5 ditë më parë

    Disney: *doesn’t make Star Wars what if* SWT: “fine I’ll do it myself”

  83. Izawa


    5 ditë më parë

    7:54 i think we forget about the fact that we talk about fucking skywalkers, you gave anakin 10 years before he defeatse palps and leia gets 15

  84. Izawa


    5 ditë më parë

    4:14 10 years, hell fucking no, he would be far more powerful than sidious max three years

  85. Kyle Hamilton

    Kyle Hamilton

    5 ditë më parë

    Lucasfilm should make a Star Wars what if show similar to marvel

  86. Gulshan Fatima

    Gulshan Fatima

    5 ditë më parë

    13:35 he is so screwed when he gets to Padme again I mean he did a lot of bad things

  87. Luis Macias

    Luis Macias

    5 ditë më parë

    Question: If Obi Wan didn’t have time to go back down the hill because of Palpatine’s arrival, how did he not encounter the emperor on the way back to his ship? How did Palpatine not impound Padme’s ship and capture her?

    • 💋 Sweety Hotgirl • Vlogs

      💋 Sweety Hotgirl • Vlogs

      3 ditë më parë

      Maul got new legs, Anakin got new legs Maul: “Noticed you’ve copied my legs”

  88. Kenneth C

    Kenneth C

    5 ditë më parë

    This is awesome! I got chills on the ending

  89. Ishaan Hodge

    Ishaan Hodge

    5 ditë më parë

    I love the fan fiction logo

    • Ishaan Hodge

      Ishaan Hodge

      3 ditë më parë

      Uh. I was talking about the intro for the video.

    • 𝐅**𝐂𝐊 A.S.S!! 𝐂𝐡𝐞𝐜𝐤

      𝐅**𝐂𝐊 A.S.S!! 𝐂𝐡𝐞𝐜𝐤

      3 ditë më parë

      “No obi-wan I have become far more powerful than YOU could have imagined” an unburnt Darth Vader said

  90. God is Good

    God is Good

    5 ditë më parë

    Can you make if all the Jedi refused to fight in the war

  91. Hollowbarista


    5 ditë më parë

    This is the epic timeline!

  92. Andres Marín Gallo

    Andres Marín Gallo

    5 ditë më parë

    dude that was so good theory! That second alternate version was incredible. Please do more! (Btw that Anakin voice was spot on lol)

    • 🔥𝐆𝐨 𝐓𝐨 𝐌𝐲 РR0FILЕ

      🔥𝐆𝐨 𝐓𝐨 𝐌𝐲 РR0FILЕ

      3 ditë më parë

      In short, Anakin would basically become a demi god.

  93. Logan Bateman

    Logan Bateman

    6 ditë më parë

    Con u pls do a fan fiction if In Vader imortal anikan brought padme back

  94. Aaron Conway

    Aaron Conway

    6 ditë më parë

    Wow 🤯 the ending with bringing balance to the force was very well done 👏👏

    • Mia - Sᴇx Cʜᴀɴɴᴇʟ 18+🅥

      Mia - Sᴇx Cʜᴀɴɴᴇʟ 18+🅥

      3 ditë më parë

      "What If Anakin didn't burn?" burns anyway

  95. JeongJeongIsWLM


    6 ditë më parë

    I’m so glad I started watching this guy in middle school

  96. oohha3


    6 ditë më parë

    When do we get to see Ep 2 of Vader Dark Date

  97. The Kilted Veteran

    The Kilted Veteran

    6 ditë më parë

    "What if Anakin didn't burn?" ...well then he wouldn't have been such a hot head. I'll see myself out

  98. Bron _

    Bron _

    6 ditë më parë

    I like the general direction of the second story, but I also feel like it does too quick of a 180 for Vader. Granted I think that happened in the actual movies a lot too so it's not unprecedented

  99. Adam D

    Adam D

    6 ditë më parë

    Tbh Palpatine would probably cripple him himself or kill him if he was not burned. He would not be blind and would have to do something about Anakin. Another thing is that Yoda’s pod was deconstructed to make his hut. Also supposedly Leia and Luke had almost the same potential if not the same as Anakin.

  100. jedimastermagus


    6 ditë më parë

    Screw as an episode. THIS should be a effin tv series that ends in a movie! MAKE IT HAPPEN UNCLE GEOGRE! Can I get a like? This would be soo bad ass!

Faqja Tjeter