What if Luke Fought Ahsoka Tano? FULL ANALYSIS Not What You Think!

Grab your free month now at www.audible.com/starwarstheory

or text Star Wars Theory to 500-500 now.

With an Audible membership, you can download titles and listen offline, anytime, anywhere. The Audible app is free and can be installed on all smartphones and tablets. You can listen across devices without losing your spot. Audible members don’t have to worry about using their credits
right away. You can keep your credits for up to a year-and use them to binge on a whole series if you’d like!
And if you’re not loving your selection, you can simply swap it for another.

_______________________________________________________________________


Welcome back to another Fantasy Battles video, where we dissect the fighting and lightsaber abilities of characters in Star Wars, then pit them against one another. Luke fighting Ahsoka in the Mandalorian Season 3 timeline would be fairly difficult of a battle. Recently, Dave Filoni has mentioned how he thinks Ahsoka Tano is Luke Skywalker's superior in lightsaber combat (and maybe more), so today let's really break this down in regards to force powers, overall power, lightsaber fighting styles, fighting psychology of each character, and overall potential.

Komente 

  1. Party Pickle

    Party Pickle

    3 ditë më parë

    Although I watch a good number of your videos that you put out, most of the time I do not comment. However, in this instance I felt compelled to do so, as this was not only very informative, but highly entertaining as well. I guess what I’m trying to say is thank you!

  2. Matt Gamble

    Matt Gamble

    3 ditë më parë

    Luke is more gifted, but Ahsoka has more training. “Talent without training is nothing.”

  3. ELManU 65

    ELManU 65

    6 ditë më parë

    If Luke could beat Darth Vader in a duel, Ashoka's chances are not that great, even with more years of experience. No duelist could ever defeat Vader, except another Skywalker. Ashoka has more experience, yes, but she would have to be in her best day to keep up with Luke. I see this duel more of a challenge for Ashoka rather than Luke having a harder time.

  4. RiceCube Tech

    RiceCube Tech

    7 ditë më parë

    I think Lukes 10 years is different than 10 years of other Jedi. One being his prodigious nature, but also that Obi Wan and Yoda as force ghosts have been training him even post death, and he has access to both sith and jedi teachings from books and holocrons that Ahsoka hasn't been shown to have.

  5. RiceCube Tech

    RiceCube Tech

    7 ditë më parë

    Ashoka gets her cheeks clapped by grandmaster luke. wait...that sounded wrong.

  6. Obi-Rob Kenobi

    Obi-Rob Kenobi

    9 ditë më parë

    There’s a great commentary on dual-wielding/double-bladed sabers in Darth Bane: Path of Destruction. Battle between Bane and Lord Kopecz. Dual-wielding isn’t necessarily more powerful, it actually hinders your possible moves. However, it’s so unique that your opponent might not be able to “guess” all the moves from the force

  7. ComputerGenerated

    ComputerGenerated

    12 ditë më parë

    I don’t know why people think Luke is so powerful just because he’s Anakin’s son. Remember, he’s only HALF Skywalker. If you look it up, Luke’s midichlorian count is roughly 15,000 thousand per cell. Ahsoka’s count is literally the same, at 15,000 per cell. So they are pretty much equally powerful. People forget that Ahsoka was a VERY ABOVE average Jedi herself. She is up there with Obi Wan and Windu who were some of the most powerful Jedi in the order. She also was the only person to have trained under the most powerful and talented force user in the history of the Galaxy. She trained for many more years than Luke, is much more skilled and experienced with both combat AND the force. She would easily destroy Luke at this time, and it would take Luke AT LEAST another decade to maybe tie with her in battle. Also she beat Darth Maul in his prime, by herself when she was 17, there’s the end of it right there. Of course she can beat Luke

  8. Riley Becerril

    Riley Becerril

    13 ditë më parë

    I think Luke still would’ve won, because he even said that using the dark and light is what’s neccessary like qui gon and this is proved in the mandalorian when mando asked ahsoka to train grogu and she said no cause he was to old and would go to the dark. This is where she is flawed he would win using both sides because he trained in those years a lot with both sides

  9. David Myhra

    David Myhra

    13 ditë më parë

    You lost me at the mention of Rey

  10. Eebram Ocgnay

    Eebram Ocgnay

    13 ditë më parë

    Luke would decimate Ahsoka and Ahsoka will be Luke's mistress and they will have more babies to continue the legacy of the Jedi.

  11. Gsup7s

    Gsup7s

    13 ditë më parë

    No freaking contest. Ahsoka would be obliterated. Why even ask that question.?

  12. Nathaniel Mooney

    Nathaniel Mooney

    13 ditë më parë

    If Luke and Ahsoka ever met, they could possibly learn a lot from each other.

  13. Jaketwix

    Jaketwix

    14 ditë më parë

    Imagine Star Wars theory on Disney...

  14. Sunny Thorn

    Sunny Thorn

    17 ditë më parë

    Also Ahsoka is not restricted by Jedi rules

  15. Paul C

    Paul C

    18 ditë më parë

    "You won't truly know someone, unless you fight them" Seraph (Matrix)

  16. KangTheConqueror

    KangTheConqueror

    19 ditë më parë

    It's obvious Luke would win

  17. thickock45

    thickock45

    20 ditë më parë

    @starwarstheory Hey bro I already have audible but i was wondering if you have a list of the books that were approved by Lucas films? I want to get a few but I'm not sure which ones to choose

  18. EnginE3r

    EnginE3r

    20 ditë më parë

    holy crap that audio intro.

  19. unLUCKY

    unLUCKY

    20 ditë më parë

    Surely with them both being in the Mandalorian they HAVE to cross paths at some point. I kind of want them to tease it for a while over a couple of Disney+ series - have them almost cross paths a few times, have Ahsoka feel his energy and recognise how similar it is to Anakin's, then finally have them meet. At the same time though, I have a hard time believing that Ahsoka doesn't know of Luke's existence 5 years after Return of the Jedi. He's a legend, the guy who went into the throne room against Palpatine and Vader and came out without a scratch, he's famous among the Rebel Alliance alone just for being the one that blew up the first Death Star... The only way I can see them making it make sense that she doesn't know of Luke is if she allowed everyone to continue believing she's dead, except the crew of the Ghost of course, so that she could remain completely undetected in her search for Thrawn, so she doesn't have any of her old contacts with the Rebel Alliance. She used to be Fulcrum, she was basically the top spy for the Rebels, she knew everything that was going on almost everywhere in the Galaxy, it was her who tipped off the crew of the Ghost multiple times and allowed them to succeed - I really struggle to believe that she wouldn't know of Luke Skywalker if she came back and was like "yo, I'm alive, what's going on guys? Keep me updated."

  20. Brandon Perkins

    Brandon Perkins

    21 ditë më parë

    Oh stop it! Compare Luke in his prime to Ashoka in her prime and legends luke is wiping the floor with Ashoka. No jedi in the history of the Jedi can beat a prime legends luke.

  21. John Groom

    John Groom

    21 ditë më parë

    Great video, they would be the best team up in Jedi history, hope we see it one day

  22. John Groom

    John Groom

    21 ditë më parë

    Luke would have his ass handed to him 🤷‍♂️

  23. Trevor Topcik

    Trevor Topcik

    22 ditë më parë

    Or in general in you’re Rey 😂

  24. Not Lazy

    Not Lazy

    22 ditë më parë

    Asoka vs Luke in return of the Jedi: Asoka wins but Asoka versus Luke in Mandalorian season two: Luke Wins

  25. Ihab Sidd

    Ihab Sidd

    22 ditë më parë

    Ashoka would definitely win

  26. bombshell782

    bombshell782

    22 ditë më parë

    2:29 you refer to Ahsoka as a form 2 makashi user. I don’t think that’s correct, she has never shown any sort makashi tendencies like Dooku does. I think she was a Form V Shien user who hybridised it with the Jar kai style as evidenced by her using a reverse hand grip like Galen Marek does and her skill with blaster deflection which Shien provided specialist training in. As for the outcome I think honestly Ahsoka would win more often than not but only just. We just haven’t seen how powerful luke is after ROJ except him destroying the dark troopers and while I’ve no doubt he would be able to hold his own against Ahsoka, I think her experience edges it in her favour. Just my opinion but a great video anyway!

  27. Greshaan SinghBhatthal

    Greshaan SinghBhatthal

    24 ditë më parë

    Didn’t Ashoka use form 4

  28. Skighte

    Skighte

    24 ditë më parë

    i think ashoka will sense the presense and power of anakin at first and then luke will show up

  29. Dungeon Monger

    Dungeon Monger

    24 ditë më parë

    Considering legends in addition to where you slated this fight to have taken place Ahsoka is actually stronger than Luke at this stage. He hasn't quite hit some of his powerspikes by this stage in his life and is still only at a mid level of control. Whereas ahsoka has gone through her full suit of encounters with Vader and sidious at this point and is closer to the peak of her power than any point previously. Also when you consider her races advantages in spacial awareness putting reduced strain on her force use while dueling and allowing her to more greatly enhance her speed and physical strength the only way Luke wins is by letting go of his calm and unleashing a full on chaotic burst of force power which he would never do against her. Also her command of various semi lost force powers is pretty significant and she's no slouch in that area. Raw power and potential Luke definitely wins. But in a head to head at this stage in their respective stories, there's no way he comes out on top against her. Especially when you notice that she's obviously barely trying when you see her in the Mandalorian. When she decides that duel is over she basically one taps her opponent. No contest, she was trying to instill fear so she could get information out of her, and it worked.

  30. Mark Ging

    Mark Ging

    25 ditë më parë

    Ashoka would look like shaak ti She’s older than Luke Her head tails must be long

  31. Rômulo Moraes

    Rômulo Moraes

    25 ditë më parë

    She wasn't a master of makashi... she was a master of ATARU... form 4...

  32. Zack Jl

    Zack Jl

    26 ditë më parë

    These two meeting in a movie or tv series would prob be one of the best scenes in star wars history

  33. MCLegend13 H

    MCLegend13 H

    26 ditë më parë

    To quote Captain Rex “In my book Experience outranks everything“ that is the truest it can be it’s quite an interesting comparison but in my opinion someone who fought in the clone wars and galactic civil war would win over Luke. Ashoka has Fought Grievous, Ventress, Maul, Inquisitiors and even Vader,

  34. Raphael Joseph Evangelista

    Raphael Joseph Evangelista

    26 ditë më parë

    Ahsoka would win as she was thought by Anakin, Obi Wan, Yoda and other masters in the temple.

  35. jmeds94

    jmeds94

    27 ditë më parë

    Mt Everest- Luke Skywalker K2- Darth Vader Kilimanjaro- Yoda Average mountain- Mace Windu/Count Dooku/Obi Wan Kenobi That hill in my backyard- Ahsoka/Qui Gon/Darth Maul

  36. Joeshmo042

    Joeshmo042

    27 ditë më parë

    Dave’s head on palps body

  37. KyleMC 22

    KyleMC 22

    27 ditë më parë

    Hmm...I might as well throw my two cents into this topic. This was a very well put together video. However, at the end of the day I'd have to give Luke the win here. Ahsoka did not specialize in makashi like you said in the video, she was an Ataru specialist in Jar Kai. It is the most labor intensive and exhausting form of Lightsaber Combat. One thing to consider is the differing practicalities of both of them at this time. Ahsoka, being 45 years old and no longer comfortably in her physical prime, is going up against a much fresher combatant using a more stalwart and pressure-oriented fighting style than her. It doesn't help that she's using a dual saber varient of Ataru, which also means she will have a harder time mounting a stronger defense against his blows because she has less leverage to work with. The skill gap between them is also not as wide as one would believe just by going off what was seen in the films. Luke was a prodigious talent with the lightsaber, a talent at adaptability that would astonish even the most notable Lightsaber Combat Instructors (Star Wars Insider 62: Fightsaber). There is a precision and control to his bladework, as seen with the second-to-last Darktrooper that he dealt with during the Mandalorian S2 Finale, and he is not nearly as temperamental or as much of a lose cannon as Anakin was by this point. The closest analogy to this fight that I could think of would be the duel between Anakin and Dooku in Revenge of The Sith, with Luke standing in for Anakin and Ahsoka standing in for Dooku. Ahsoka is a more classically learned swordswoman, having more practical teaching in regards to her bladework. However, their practical application of their dueling skills I see as being on relatively equal footing. It is Luke's better shape, greater strength in the force, adaptability, and more suitable lightsaber technique that I believe will carry him through this fight and ultimately wear her down.... Or until ghost dad Anakin pops up and gets his kids to stop fighting. Anyways, here's just my humble opinion on it. Keep up the good work! :)

  38. Jonathan Hernandez

    Jonathan Hernandez

    27 ditë më parë

    This would be sick if it happened

  39. Rowan B

    Rowan B

    27 ditë më parë

    I'm surprised Rey didn't turn out to be her own father

  40. Dylan Lewis

    Dylan Lewis

    27 ditë më parë

    I've got the huge book that collects Labyrinth of Evil, Revenge of the Sith novelization, and Dark Lord. One of the things that always stuck with me was how the Clone Commandos of Ion Team handled Order 66. They didn't trust it. They thought it might be a Separatist hack. They even defended their Jedi against the other Clones. Ion Team was later executed.

  41. Seth Miller

    Seth Miller

    27 ditë më parë

    Ahsoka is one of my all time favorite characters she is what rey should've been but when it comes to force powers between luke and her i'd bet more on ahsoka and she is more agile then luke by a long shot so luke getting distance is a big if but ahsoka in the force is no push over and she is very quick and accurate with her force pushes and jumps and speed so i don't think luke is more powerful then her in the force i believe she passes him in the mando like her potential as a padawan was exceptional and she was a fast learner just like luke so i think she can beat luke 9/10.

  42. Jeremy Pintsize

    Jeremy Pintsize

    28 ditë më parë

    "Alone they are already badasses , as a team they will be a death sentence." Anonymous veterant stormtrooper

  43. Jorge Carbajal

    Jorge Carbajal

    29 ditë më parë

    It would be interesting to see a sparring session between the two, especially if Ahsoka teaches Luke the same lessons she learned from Anakin. In Vader’s words, “The circle is now complete.”

  44. dy

    dy

    29 ditë më parë

    "Emotions run strong in the Skywalker family." Galen to Vader: *I WILL KILL YOU!*

  45. Omar Taha

    Omar Taha

    Muaj më parë

    I listened to this baked AF! And it was ridiculously epic! The way you narrated your theory was brilliant!

  46. Melinda Melow

    Melinda Melow

    Muaj më parë

    I hate to call you out but you stole my idea

    • Melinda Melow

      Melinda Melow

      27 ditë më parë

      Don’t worry about it I don’t wanna waste your time I give up

    • Shreyansh Dhakad

      Shreyansh Dhakad

      27 ditë më parë

      @Melinda Melow Its two popular characters, in a matchup, not some in depth fanfic lore. What precision are you talking about?

    • Melinda Melow

      Melinda Melow

      27 ditë më parë

      So similar to my idea it’s uncanny

    • Melinda Melow

      Melinda Melow

      27 ditë më parë

      That would be enough to deter me but the thing is it’s just so damn precise

    • Shreyansh Dhakad

      Shreyansh Dhakad

      28 ditë më parë

      this is a common matchup...................

  47. Darth DewIt!

    Darth DewIt!

    Muaj më parë

    Did anyone else read the thumbnail like the voice from Mortal Kombat?

  48. Jose Colon

    Jose Colon

    Muaj më parë

    Don’t agree. At the peak of her power Ashoka was near defeat to Vader if it not for Ezra. However, Luke brought Vader to the small of his back only raising an exhausted hand between himself and Luke’s saber. Ashoka never achieved the realization of Jedi Knight. Luke however, despite his impatience and foolishness to rush Vader, overcame his great fear that Vader is his father. That achieved the control between emotion and the Force completing her training. This is something we never saw from Tano. She never overcame the fear of Vader being her beloved master. If you know of Bruce Lee, that would be Ashoka. Never completing her training in Wing Chun but smart enough to look at herself honestly and train to compensate the gaps in her knowledge to become formidable as Bruce did with JKD. However, despite this was never able to beat her master as Bruce was never able to best his teacher Wong Shun Leung. Luke did complete his training and branched out to other forms to completion allowing him to have a larger more practiced arsenal in training than Ashoka ever had. This is a great conversation. Thanks for the video!

  49. Xael31

    Xael31

    Muaj më parë

    Luke is hope, Luke is the spark of redemption, Luke is the strongest lightside force user ever (for his age). Sorry I really like Ahsoka but she's no match. I don't think that anyone can beat Luke in 1v1 after ROTJ.

  50. Elizabeth Goree

    Elizabeth Goree

    Muaj më parë

    So... they both win? I would love for them to meet.

  51. Buried Alien

    Buried Alien

    Muaj më parë

    Easy answer: Luke would win if they fought.

  52. Craig P

    Craig P

    Muaj më parë

    I wonder if Anakin already spoke to Ashoka once he became a force ghost. I can see Luke telling her. And she saying, “I know”… Han Solo style!

  53. _ Nomad

    _ Nomad

    Muaj më parë

    Luke has the worst am fighting stance in amd he uses his friends so much to a point of exhaustion he should have his own friend card ☣️

  54. Haydn Pashby

    Haydn Pashby

    Muaj më parë

    As far as prime versions go, luke stomps, however at this stage I'd say luke cant use his powers in a way that is able to best Ahsoka, shes to experienced and a much better duelist. I think Luke's force attacks would be like a boxer throwing haymakers, powerful but telegraphed and easily avoidable. You have to remember that this is luke 5yrs after ROTJ, he is on his own, without a teacher at the moment and there hasn't exactly been any other powerful force users for him to sparr with lately. Hes been forced to teach himself, which would make jumping into this duel very difficult him.

  55. Rhade

    Rhade

    Muaj më parë

    Some nerd lightsaber combat style facts: Ahsoka haven’t used Makashi before Jar’Kai, at least we haven’t seen it. Before she got her shoto, she used Shien (the reverse grip is used only in Shien, other lightsaber forms use conventional grip - not talking about Jar’Kai variation of Niman here) Luke has a unique lightsaber combat style, not just Djem-So, like Anakin. He “borrowed” it from Vader after their confrontation in Ep.5. Vader, however, developed it due to his injuries and inability to move swiftly, like Anakin once did. He created his form, using Djem-So as base and took its raw power tendency, took Makashis precision strikes and dueling capabilities and, at last, took Soresus blaster deflection technique (which compensated his lack of agility).

  56. kawhyyy doutry

    kawhyyy doutry

    Muaj më parë

    Maul vs grevious in both primes would be awesome

  57. Julián Yo

    Julián Yo

    Muaj më parë

    There is only one form: formless. Shapeless. Be water, my friend.

  58. Revan of Krypton

    Revan of Krypton

    Muaj më parë

    Darth Revan vs Luke... who do you think would win?

  59. anthony taggart

    anthony taggart

    Muaj më parë

    But Ray used both Skywalker light sabers to defeat Sith eternal Palps.

  60. Juliano Martins

    Juliano Martins

    Muaj më parë

    Despite Luke inherited the power his father had, he would get his ass kicked by Ahsoka. She had more training.

  61. Tbonyandsteak

    Tbonyandsteak

    Muaj më parë

    Nothing beat battle experience, Luke would be toast. Well if he would face me??? He would also lose.

  62. Thedeepseanomad

    Thedeepseanomad

    Muaj më parë

    We all know Luke in the Mandelorian would steam-roll Ahsoka and disarm her pretty fast. Then cook some food for her. Luke has shown he is very proficient in using force attacks during combat, no?

  63. Kohl

    Kohl

    Muaj më parë

    All over the place. At one time Luke is quicker, at another Ashoka is quicker. I plan on watching the clone wars, but from what I gathered by researching strengths styles and force, Ashoka beats Luke, and it's not even a question. Ashoka's speed is on another level. I saw a scene on youtube where she literally sensed the events of Anakin betrayal across the galaxy word for word. She is close to Yoda level force master. Finally. Luke was anything but a Jedi when he fought Vader. Displaying all the things a Jedi should not do. Ashoka stands in the middle. Unaffected by both light and dark. She has no weakness of the force.

  64. Avengemonus prime

    Avengemonus prime

    Muaj më parë

    again i still dont understand why ashoka in the mandalorian didnt use the force that much

  65. Discount Wolverine

    Discount Wolverine

    Muaj më parë

    I don’t think it would be that close unfortunately. If Din Djarin can hold his own against Ahsoka, yet almost get killed by one Dark Trooper, and Luke can just delete the whole squad, Luke can easy defeat her. Luke is ridiculously skilled naturally, also being far more powerful. Skywalker is just too powerful for Tano

  66. The Jedi Archives

    The Jedi Archives

    Muaj më parë

    Twilight of the Master

  67. James Puso

    James Puso

    Muaj më parë

    Ya know, the more I think about it, not that we'd ever see Luke fight this way but if he could casually force crush a dark trooper... well imagine what that would do to flesh and bone. He probably couldn't do that, it's against his nature in his right mind and even when he gets triggered and darker impulses kick in he probably can't focus that enough to do it to someone but that does give some idea of just how powerful his force abilities are. In that regard I kinda see it going a lot like her fight with Vader, she probably had the advantage as a lightsaber duelist but a couple force pushes was all he needed.

  68. Marcelino Solis

    Marcelino Solis

    Muaj më parë

    Ashoka vs Luke feels like dom vs Sean in Tokyo drift something we all wanted to see the outcome of but rather leave to imagination

  69. Alex

    Alex

    Muaj më parë

    Lets be real, Ahsoka would completely overwhelm him anywhere, anytime.

  70. Dylan Aguirre

    Dylan Aguirre

    Muaj më parë

    Why would they Fight ? Ashoka: I will not let you make the same mistakes as your father (dual blades turn on) Luke: Your Judgment is clouded (his hands separate and hide in his cloak) You don't have to do this Ashoka: I will do what I must(attacks)

  71. Dylan Aguirre

    Dylan Aguirre

    Muaj më parë

    Luke isn't afraid to use the force on someone, he's against it but he will destroy you if he has to, even in a cage match luke would get tired but will give his final warning and if Ashoka continues her attack... he'll stop holding back. He would wack one of her lightsabers away and Will have the upper hand on strength since he's used to form V and Ashoka is not, you do have point on experience but Luke from the mandolorian is not Anakin from attack of the clones he is much more wise and more experienced than Anakin from episode 2. He is not more experienced than Ashoka but he is way too powerful in every, way he's not more powerful than his father but he is a better Jedi than anyone was or will ever be the Son of the chosen one is OP

  72. Stefan Bajic

    Stefan Bajic

    Muaj më parë

    I dont see her beating mando Luke ever, in any setting.

  73. Tim

    Tim

    Muaj më parë

    Gotta disagree - there are two handed strikes, blocks, and parries that essentially imitate a single blade with two hands. Agree on the force part, though, unless/until they have mastered the form beyond thought.

  74. Christian

    Christian

    Muaj më parë

    I predict Ahsoka will meet Luke in the season finalie of Mandalorian season 3, after Anakin appears as a force ghost "vision" when she gets knocked out during the siege of Mandalore 2.0 . Almost identical to Obi Wan and Luke on Hoth. Then the season ends with Din Seeing Grogu, and Ahsoka meeting Luke, which then Goes directly into the Ahsoka Tano show.

  75. Nikolay Tkach

    Nikolay Tkach

    Muaj më parë

    3:30 So if lightning should be deflected you would rather have 1 lightsaber that you hold with 2 hands rather than 2 lightsabers Unless you're Rey

  76. Anton Martynyuk

    Anton Martynyuk

    Muaj më parë

    Nice one! But I think that Luke will beat Ahsoka in any type of combat

  77. Väinö Rajaniemi

    Väinö Rajaniemi

    Muaj më parë

    Can you do rebels maul vs rebels ashoka i think maul wins

  78. Erogama

    Erogama

    Muaj më parë

    I would say that even if Ahsoka has had more time and experience in the Force/lightsaber combat, Luke's 10 years of training more than make up for it. Even if Vader was holding back against Luke in ROTJ, it's still true that Luke was able to spar with him where countless other Jedi didn't last a minute. Ofc Ahsoka fought a bloodlusted Vader and basically lost, but this was still a much weaker version of Vader compared to the one Luke fought. Luke also isn't like Anakin who took his training for granted and relied almost exclusively on his talent. Luke learned to take his training seriously after his defeat on Bespin and he would have kept that lesson to heart because he knows he's now the only one who can continue the Jedi lineage. So Luke with 10 years of training would be superior to Anakin with that same amount of time. With that said, I would say Luke wins at least 8 times out of 10 against Ahsoka in any given scenario. His only real disadvantage MIGHT be that he hasn't really fought a lot of other Force users in the 10 years after the Empire's fall (if any since I don't follow Disney canon, but Legends Luke faced Palpatine again, Mara Jade, literally himself, and Joruus C'baoth to name a few by the time Mandalorian takes place, the latter of whom would also absolutely stomp Ahsoka, but they all have a completely different scaling so I digress). However, the same is true for Ahsoka so it's not really much of a disadvantage.

  79. AeroSnail

    AeroSnail

    Muaj më parë

    They should fight over dark side Ezra, controlled by Thrawn. A three sided light saber, ending with Luke and Ahsoka becoming allies to bring Ezra back and destroy Thrawn.

  80. im jellis

    im jellis

    Muaj më parë

    Dude I would lose my shit if Ashoka talked to Anakin’s force ghost

  81. Darth maul

    Darth maul

    Muaj më parë

    in my timeline this is impossible i killed ashoka in the clonewars

  82. En Glarreman

    En Glarreman

    Muaj më parë

    I Think Luke winns all the time

  83. Matthew Skywalker

    Matthew Skywalker

    Muaj më parë

    I definitely want to see them on screen together, but as friends. I don't want to see them fight (unless they're sparring).

  84. Filip Češnjak

    Filip Češnjak

    Muaj më parë

    Luke Skywalker at this point is much powerfull that he was in Return of the Jedi, his force powers are much more powerfull than Ashokas, he is padawan no more and has a lot of fighting expirience, Luke also did much better in his fight angaint Darth Vader then Ashoka did, in lightsaber combat they could be equal in this point in time, overall Luke > Ashoka

  85. Ayrton Christian Braga

    Ayrton Christian Braga

    Muaj më parë

    Makashi? I though Ahsoka specialized in Shien as a padawan

  86. Evan Washington

    Evan Washington

    Muaj më parë

    Well according the Geoge Lucas Luke was evenly matched with Darth Vader in return of the Jedi and that's saying alot as Vader is up to 80% of Darth Sidious full power so Luke would win

  87. KUNTAR

    KUNTAR

    Muaj më parë

    If they had a training sequence filmed in Hollywood today, Ahsoka would win - because female.

  88. Sensei

    Sensei

    Muaj më parë

    If Anakin speaks to Ahsoka in the “Ahsoka” show, if the acting and music is right, I’d probably cry and I never cry lol

  89. ALr

    ALr

    Muaj më parë

    So no clear answer? Thanks. That should’ve been first

  90. Battle Axe

    Battle Axe

    Muaj më parë

    Luke would destroy her.

  91. Darth Necronis

    Darth Necronis

    Muaj më parë

    The logic for this encounter is quite impressive. I agree with your conclusion.

  92. lgy007

    lgy007

    Muaj më parë

    I aslo think Luke is overall stronger, but Ashoka is way more experienced and trained in dueling. I mean lets face it, in canon Luke only fought Vader, who never really intended to kill him in the first place. Also, Luke is more like a self-taught duelist with probaly having nothing but texts or holocrons to go with after briefly training with Yoda, while Ashoka trained with the best in person and dueled with several legendary characters including the likes of Maul or Vader (who in that case definitely wanted to kill her).

  93. Dvs

    Dvs

    Muaj më parë

    Ahsoka would kick Lukes's ass. She is a seasoned warrior. She sent her whole life in war. Plus under the tutelage of Anakin Skywalker, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Yoda... Luke can’t even touch that.

  94. david belzer

    david belzer

    Muaj më parë

    This definitely feels like old school starwars theroy love it

  95. Nathan Holliday

    Nathan Holliday

    Muaj më parë

    They should meet at Thrawn. The last great Jedi of the fallen Republic tracking down the last great military leader of the fallen empire and crossing paths with the son of the chosen one on his own mission to track down the remaining leaders of the empire. I could just see Ashoka drawing her blades when Luke tells her his name. Them each trying to explain who they are to one another and how they are connected to Anakin Skywalker. The connection they make as they discuss who Anakin was what he became and how he returned. Then Ashoka passing on all the skill and knowledge she has gained since she was Anakin padawan to his son Luke. Luke learning and growing initially not as good with the force or saber combat as Ashoka but gradually getting better until he surpasses her highest possible potential and continues to grow. And together reforming the Jedi order and learning from the mistakes of the former. Training themselves and their pupils not to fear emotion, to use it, but never let it control them. And truly becoming galactic protectors far more powerful than the mightiest the dark side could ever conjure to oppose them.

  96. Nathan Holliday

    Nathan Holliday

    Muaj më parë

    I understand Luke is one of the most iconic characters ever. But any version of him we see on the big screen would get his tale kicked versus Ashoka. Ashoka is better trained and more experienced. She has fought, won, and survived against some of the greatest dualists the galaxy has ever seen. Luke only beat Vader because Anakin wouldn’t kill his son. This battle would go to Ashoka and from what we know about the sequels it always will. Luke has been destroyed by Disney. Ashoka earned her skill through two animated tv series while Luke got downgraded from force god to hermit. I would love to see him learn from Ashoka and gradually get better until he could beat her and ultimately surpass her but in current Star Wars cannon I don’t believe it can or probably should happen.

  97. KT Gaming

    KT Gaming

    Muaj më parë

    imagine if during the fight Ahsoka will recognize that lukes fighting is similar and say something

  98. Powers Lohner

    Powers Lohner

    Muaj më parë

    How would luke not win

  99. Nathan Holliday

    Nathan Holliday

    Muaj më parë

    Audible is honestly the greatest invention ever! Listening to books is a great way to enjoy books if you aren’t fond of reading.

  100. Barry Allen

    Barry Allen

    Muaj më parë

    In reality Ahsoka definitely should win Luke would only be stronger in the force

Faqja Tjeter