What if Anakin Fought Luke Skywalker Prime - FULL Analysis

The most difficult versus series episode I've ever done. Luke Skywalker (Mandalorian Season 2) vs Anakin Skywalker (Revenge of the Sith). Anakin and Luke are my favorite characters, so this is very tough and unbiased for me to analyse...but I believe my analysis is fair and with reasons.
Anakin Skywalker in Revenge of the Sith was still brash, arrogant, untamed. While stronger than Luke, Luke was more focused, more calm, more of a true Jedi Master...more like Qui-Gon Jinn.
Luke Skywalker (Mandalorian Season 2 version) was a much more powerful version of Obi-Wan Kenobi (Revenge of the Sith). Obi-Wan wasn't ask powerful as Anakin, yet he still won. Why? Because he waited for Anakin to make an error. He waited for the opening. He stayed consistent in his defence long enough for Anakin to faulter, and that's why he won. Not because he was more powerful, but because he was more experienced. More level headed. More patient.
I believe if Luke can take Anakin out quickly, before Anakin's rage continues to climb, then Luke wins.
If Luke drags the battle on, Anakin will continue to gain the upper hand...until...Luke loses his last real one...

I posted a forum thread about this, see what the community has to say about this fight - starwarstheory.com/THEORY/pos...

New episode on Spotify, check it out right now! just type in Star Wars Theory
I promise you will enjoy it.

Become a Patron to support future content - www.patreon.com/StarWarsTheory

Join this channel to get access to perks:
alpast.info/tax/8Cb...

Komente 

  1. Star Wars Theory

    Star Wars Theory

    27 ditë më parë

    Who wins?

    • Adiyan Shaikh

      Adiyan Shaikh

      9 orë më parë

      Anakin is supreme.

    • ANDY LIKES

      ANDY LIKES

      2 ditë më parë

      @Jed Z it's a generational thing we had years without star wars after ROTJ apart from books comics ewok movies droids cartoons family guy trilogy that at the time was awesome because it was star wars lol

    • ANDY LIKES

      ANDY LIKES

      2 ditë më parë

      @StarWarsTheroy the question is why did luke use rage against a Dark Trooper 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

    • Chris Bradley

      Chris Bradley

      2 ditë më parë

      Anakin would crush Luke, if you’d made them both the same age, whether you made Anakin 28, or Luke 22. The longer Anakin fights, the more powerful he becomes, as you stated. Yes he’s cocky, yes he thinks he’s invincible. But at the end of the day, he’s stronger, taller, and, in my own opinion, more skilled in form 5. Yes he’s not as skilled with his using forces, due to him always being more focused on his lightsaber combat skills. But I really think that Anakin is just more powerful than Luke. And even if Luke bested Anakin, it wouldn’t necessarily be a fair fight, because in your scenario, Luke is 6 years older than Anakin. If you aged Anakin to 28 as well, with all his limbs, Anakin would beat Luke like it was nothing. Mainly due to, theoretically speaking, Anakin still having the advantage of experience and, potentially, honing his powers of the force and his lightsaber combat even more. If you aged down Luke to 22, Anakin would still beat him, due to his longer years of training. As I said, this is just my own opinion, and if anyone disagrees, that’s totally fair. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and theories. I support, and encourage everyone to have their opinions, and I love reading everyone else’s comments, and supporting knowledge for their opinions/theories on who would ultimately win. While I don’t think you’re scenario, as in you Star Wars Theory (if you even see this/ever read this, but I still think your analysis in this video is pretty accurate. Given the cannon timeline events, due to Anakin turning to the dark side at 22, being bested by his old master due to his own arrogance and over confidence in his old and newly learned abilities. If you’d aged Anakin up to 28 in this video while sticking to the canon events of him having already lost his limbs and burned, as well as him still trying to fully adjust his fighting skills to mesh with his suit. That would definitely lead to Luke beating Anakin/Vader, whilst still quite a bit of a struggle, it wouldn’t be a super long fight, and Luke would defeat Anakin/Vader without terrible difficulty. I also acknowledge that if you made Luke 22 in this fight, and sticking to canon, I assume, due to possibly not knowing/reading, or if info even existing on him at that age, that Luke would totally lose to Anakin. Whether it be post turning to the dark side or him still being a Jedi (then again Vader at that time was new to the dark side and thus isn’t totally knowledgeable/experienced with all the Sith abilities), as Anakin had more training, lightsaber combat with Sith, Jedi and in general forces users. But like I stated earlier in this long winded comment, I think that your analysis and outcome in this theoretical battle between Anakin and Luke is accurate, and Anakin would lose after a decently length fight. Anyway, I love your videos. Keep up the fun, fantastic, and amazing work your doing and have been for years! I look forward to even more fanfic videos! Here’s to many more years of success for you!

    • Dancerv

      Dancerv

      2 ditë më parë

      Anakin!

  2. Death trooper

    Death trooper

    10 orë më parë

    ► Ahsoka Tano Remembers: alpast.info/one/video/nX5-1dGkeWrXhNg

  3. Harry Navedo

    Harry Navedo

    11 orë më parë

    U made way to many assumptions about luke with his training and because of that it doesnt make sense trying to make this fight reality based. If u went on what we actually saw Anakins training with all the masters in the temple paired with the combat experience from the clone wars alone would give anakin the greater advantage in the fight.

  4. Crease Mason

    Crease Mason

    12 orë më parë

    Luke wins... Anakin never reached his full potential. Anakin was incredibly powerful, but overly-aggressive and reckless... Luke uses his composure, is defensively sound, waits for the mistake to happen & capitalises...

  5. xtc teen

    xtc teen

    17 orë më parë

    CAN YOU DO EP 6 LUKE VS CLONE WARS DOOKU

  6. Rich Saulnier

    Rich Saulnier

    Ditë më parë

    Umm should I bother pointing out....he did

  7. Bxgodson2fl2

    Bxgodson2fl2

    Ditë më parë

    Good analysis!

  8. Juan Laise

    Juan Laise

    Ditë më parë

    Anakin in his prime is stated to be inferior to Vader. Vader and Luke were equals as of ROTJ. Luke would defeat Anakin.

  9. captain.ravioli

    captain.ravioli

    Ditë më parë

    Yo this guys vids are always a w

  10. JG32

    JG32

    Ditë më parë

    “You’re over confidence is your weakness.” Truer words have never been spoken by Luke to describe this kind of fight.

  11. Swedish-pirate

    Swedish-pirate

    2 ditë më parë

    i would say Anakin, it would be a close one, but Anakin having all that battle experience fighting front line again and again plus all of the duels, is a big difference plus adding chosen one on top of that, personally i think Anakin would maybe win 3:1 times, Luke having a chance if Anakin where to slip up and being arrogant.

  12. Syde Kontrol

    Syde Kontrol

    2 ditë më parë

    Anakin would also struggle going to the dark side against his son.

  13. Syde Kontrol

    Syde Kontrol

    2 ditë më parë

    Luke pulled a Star Destroyer out of Orbit.... Legends Luke destroys Emotional Anny

  14. Dancerv

    Dancerv

    2 ditë më parë

    Anakin skywalker would win

  15. ZM Fox

    ZM Fox

    2 ditë më parë

    I feel like it would either end up like Kenobi v Maul in Rebels, where Luke would be wise enough to end in 2 strikes, or it would be a straight up slugfest between the 2 and Anakin would have the endurance. But it also imply that Anakin or Luke know each other. If so I feel like Luke would try to talk to Anakin. And it would either anger Anakin or it would just end in a stalemate. Luke was a fighter, but he had that Obi-Wan Negotiator built into him. But pound for pound I believe Luke would win. He achieved his own balance, by using the force as his ally. Not as a tool, and using the flow and achieving his solidarity, he can use it to keep up with Anakin and bide his time. Like Obi-Wan before him, but Luke would have more precision and deadliness. Clone Wars did a lot for Anakin, but here's something we have to consider, most of the time he was assisted by Obi-Wan. Anakin is unorthodox, but he never did it alone most of the time. It is true by the end of the clone wars he became an excellent soldier. Contrast, Luke was a soldier but not in the force. He only really tapped into the force at the end of Empire and off and on in the comics. And he did have book smarts but not the Jedi soldier experience that Anakin had. Like you said, and I agree. Anakin fuels off the anger, and when he becomes Lord Vader on Mustafar he is argubly in his fullest state. But he never got to harnass that anger, and it caused his downfall. I believe Luke would win.

  16. Bryce____111

    Bryce____111

    3 ditë më parë

    Canon Luke gets desimated by anakin.

  17. The Real Retro Beard

    The Real Retro Beard

    3 ditë më parë

    I'm hoping in season 3 of Mando we get to see a flashback of Ahsoka training Luke. I feel Lukes hands on training is far more than we presume. His bladework in Mando season 2 was calm, controlled and precise. At this point I think he's a match for any Jedi or Sith.

  18. HyperionSF

    HyperionSF

    3 ditë më parë

    Luke has more potential, but Anakin is more experienced and refined. Anakin wins hands down.

  19. Imaginary Fiend

    Imaginary Fiend

    3 ditë më parë

    Depends on lukes age in the match. Return of the jedi Luke would be annihilated in about an quarter hour, IMHO. The later grandmaster Luke would probably try to somewhat spare anakin and therefore drag out the fight longer than necessary but could pretty much end it at will at a moments notice if need be.

    • Ace Gabriel Cruz

      Ace Gabriel Cruz

      Ditë më parë

      @Imaginary Fiend Luke only trained for 4 years while Anakin trained for 13 years so how is Luke more versatile in the force

    • Imaginary Fiend

      Imaginary Fiend

      3 ditë më parë

      Addendum: Anakin is the better swordsman, but I would object to him being more versatile in the application of the force. Luke is a master of the dark and the light side.

  20. Gabriel Gardner

    Gabriel Gardner

    4 ditë më parë

    In just a flat out fight there’s no way Luke beats Aniken. Aniken had been trained since he was 10 years old and spent like half of his life actually fighting in wars and other forced users. Doesn’t matter how much time you spend in a dojo training with masters which Anakin still had more of that anyways but that doesn’t even compare to actual in the field fighting. And Aniken has years of practice. I think that you can’t really count Obi-Wan beating Aniken. I think that could’ve only happened in that exact situation with extreme emotional conflict. Also Obi-Wan had literally been fighting/ sparring with Aniken for decades at that point.

  21. Sam Nash

    Sam Nash

    4 ditë më parë

    i think anakin would have won

  22. Meideiocre

    Meideiocre

    4 ditë më parë

    >Luke is smaller Judge him by his size, will you?

  23. Chase

    Chase

    4 ditë më parë

    Mando Luke loses to Anakin post-clone wars. Anakin fought in multiple wars and has been calm and collected. The only reason why he was blinded by rage was that Obi-Wan brought Padme with him. Luke up to this point has not had hard fights against Darkside wielders. Anakin beating Dooku and the literal embodiment of the Darkside proves that he is stronger.

  24. Alex Hare

    Alex Hare

    5 ditë më parë

    Remember that we saw Anakin as much troubled as one can get fighting the only Jedi who knew him well. We won't get any more proof that he would have become unbeatable but from George who said it was a fact. I say Anakin 100%

  25. Sean Springer

    Sean Springer

    5 ditë më parë

    This makes me think of something different. What would have happened if anakin was trained by someone else. For example, yoda or mace windew?

  26. Andres Marín Gallo

    Andres Marín Gallo

    6 ditë më parë

    I have to go with Luke! great video!!!!

  27. tony odorisio

    tony odorisio

    6 ditë më parë

    Yoda vs Mace Windu 💚💜

  28. Darth Welder

    Darth Welder

    6 ditë më parë

    Keep up the great work theory! I had such a fun time at the st Jude stream I really liked everyone you had on.

  29. Joako Spamer

    Joako Spamer

    6 ditë më parë

    I agree luke is like a combination of obi wan and anakin, timing beats speed and Luke would have been able to read his father and use superior force abilities to stop him

  30. Justin Crider

    Justin Crider

    6 ditë më parë

    Not even. Anakin would win no matter the circumstances. These luke fan boys need to calm down and stop underestimating the chosen one.

  31. yaboi frankie

    yaboi frankie

    6 ditë më parë

    I barely disagree

  32. Steven Sharp

    Steven Sharp

    6 ditë më parë

    Anakin/Vader never really wanted to kill Luke and once he realized Luke was willing to die to save him, he would lose his edge. Anakin was never invested in the dark side so he wouldn't go all out on Luke, and that would weaken him. That's why and how Luke wins.

  33. Sam

    Sam

    6 ditë më parë

    I think people ignore the inherent advantage Obi-Wan has as he was Anakin's best friend and mentor, he had fought alongside and trained Anakin for years. His knowledge of Anakin helped a lot in his fight and I don't think it's fair to treat that fight as if anyone with Obi-Wan's abilities would have won.

  34. JJ Jones

    JJ Jones

    7 ditë më parë

    To me Vader was weak in the end when he removed his helmet and didn't fight to the death like Sidious. He's always had this tiny weakness in him. This is just enough weakness to give Luke the advantage.

  35. Patrick Oplinger

    Patrick Oplinger

    7 ditë më parë

    Hard to say. Just don’t bring up Luke’s sister - or it’s ON

  36. Al ntite Fqer

    Al ntite Fqer

    7 ditë më parë

    Anikan had more game at the age of nine than luke had up to crucible but luke would definitely win not to mention at 30 luke rebuilt the Jedi academy .!.!. Fπ¢k the parallel universe that is disney i say boycott the lies let's find a way to get the real star wars that they threw away , a part of public domain so we can continue the real universe

  37. Alfred Bernal

    Alfred Bernal

    7 ditë më parë

    Obi defeated anakin & Obi let Darth Vader defeat him...enough said

  38. Informative Bro

    Informative Bro

    7 ditë më parë

    Anakin defeated a sith lord Luke got defeated by a sith lord Anakin should win

  39. Renzy jay Arquintillo

    Renzy jay Arquintillo

    7 ditë më parë

    Luke has the high ground 😅

  40. William J. Dove, Jr.

    William J. Dove, Jr.

    7 ditë më parë

    Obi-Wan was Luke's guiding star.. fighting style, temper, everything.. Luke became the strongest Jedi in the galaxy.

  41. William J. Dove, Jr.

    William J. Dove, Jr.

    7 ditë më parë

    Let's not forget that in the expanded universe beginning..Luke became so powerful that he was able to bring down a AT-AT just by raising his arm...Luke would dig deep to win.

  42. BJETNT

    BJETNT

    7 ditë më parë

    I'm with you I think Luke is still my favorite character of all time in Star wars although I have to admit when I read about abeloth I would love to see her in a movie. If they did that right that movie would be the best selling Star wars movie ever especially with Luke joining hands with the sith to go after abeloth

  43. Owesk Jast

    Owesk Jast

    8 ditë më parë

    In his prime? Luke never fought him at his best and still would have lost to Vader. If he was to fight Anakin at his best he’d be destroyed. No contest.

  44. BensonSooner

    BensonSooner

    8 ditë më parë

    Luke would have destroyed him

  45. Chris Gomez

    Chris Gomez

    8 ditë më parë

    I truly believe if Darth Maul did not kill Quigon Jin and he was able to train him Anakin would've never fall to the dark side. Quinn Jin knew how powerful he was and he would've trained him with no restrictions.

  46. Crunchy

    Crunchy

    8 ditë më parë

    Make one where luke time travels to the clone wars

  47. Yoseph Butler

    Yoseph Butler

    8 ditë më parë

    Anakin STOMPS... of course not easily but anakin is better

  48. Erik Pepper

    Erik Pepper

    8 ditë më parë

    Luke would win, hands down. He war the real Chosen One before Disney/China.

  49. Daniel Freer

    Daniel Freer

    9 ditë më parë

    If we r talking legends luke, anakin stands zero chance.

  50. Jovica Materic

    Jovica Materic

    9 ditë më parë

    Anakin loses because he is too human

  51. Nate

    Nate

    9 ditë më parë

    George Lucas has said that they both have the same potential. Luke is at the height of his power in S2 Mandalorian. Ergo Luke wins

  52. stephen caramenico

    stephen caramenico

    9 ditë më parë

    It’s not even close. Anakin by a mile.

  53. fj nagel

    fj nagel

    9 ditë më parë

    Well it gets even more interesting if you'd consider legends, and how anakin was a medium of the force, to balance itself. So if legends Luke would be the most powerful force user of the lightside, anakin would have the potential to at least be the same level as him. (I mean anakin brought balance to the force by killing the Jedi order, leaving obiwan and Yoda, against Vader and palpatine, eventually taking obiwans, then Yoda's place)

  54. Kal Solo

    Kal Solo

    9 ditë më parë

    I think Luke would come out on top, patience is key and Anakins arrogance would again be his downfall. I don’t think Luke would ever kill Anakin, though

  55. Paul Henke

    Paul Henke

    9 ditë më parë

    i dont think that that Anakin was so much more powerful, anakin and luke had nearly the same amount of midiclorians so Luke in his prime (we talking about full potential) would wreck anakin just with the force, he wouldnt need no lightsaber! But i think you mean the point where luke was in his prime and not reached his full potential. Even then i would not count anakin over luke, just because of lukes strong bond with the force. If we look at what he did on crait, i would say that luke mastered the force better then anakin ever had. Force projection is a technique not very many masters had learned or even mastered. It requires extreme focus and concentration. Using this power was extremely taxing; Kylo Ren noted that Rey, whose power in the Force rivaled his own immense powers as a Skywalker, would die just by trying. Although Luke Skywalker maintained a projection for several minutes, giving all of himself to the Force to allow him to physically interact with his surroundings, the strain cost him his life. I think anakin would attack very aggressively and bravely, luke would probably be rather unimpressed and would first fight defensively and later after anakin is already a bit exhausted, fight much more aggressively. At that point I think that Anakin relies more on his strength in power and fights more carefully because he notices that he is not achieving anything with his aggressive nature. From that point on it depends a lot on how luke works, he has to be careful because even if Luke may know more about the power, anakin has a lot more experience in lightsaber combat. During the lightsaber fight to use the force, I trust hatch a little more, he has used more of his potential. Anakin's overconfidence would probably cost him his life in the long run, even if I think that the two of them don't take much away from each other when it comes to 1-on-1 skills. I would also call Luke a gray Jedi because he masters the stranglehold without being aggressive. Anakin was only able to do this when angry or frustrated. Both can win this fight, I would say they both have a 50% chance.

    • A Tale’s Truth

      A Tale’s Truth

      8 ditë më parë

      Never use sequels feats for Luke because the force projection thing is BS on him dying based on the fact rey and kylo an interact through time and space without dying and teleport matter itself A feat far greater then simply sending an illusion In the EU luke when he first used it did end up looking like palatine with the rages and everything because of how much strain it was putting on him but if didn’t kill him, as well but he mastered the ability to the point that wouldn’t happen and learned to teleport matter and himself but that took years to even do, Luke in the EU was basically a student of the force he used the light and dark but for good, darkness leads to evil as he says but it’s not evil itself, but like how the color isn’t good or bad it’s what it’s used for that makes it good to bad, The only other jedi before luke that actually has full mastery over light and dark was Revan who while not a skywalker was indeed the pinicle of balance before luke As for you analysis on luke and Anakin in general relatively speaking they be equal who wins a fight comes down to the mindset or training of the two, given Anakin is the father and being older, if in his prime compared to a younger luke Anakin would win regardless until luke gets about that level in which he still won’t have the same experience as his father, but at the same age if Luke is more level headed and Anakin is still arrogant luke wins

  56. Seeve

    Seeve

    9 ditë më parë

    Anakin obviously

  57. Ron Dutertre

    Ron Dutertre

    9 ditë më parë

    Luke has the power to tap into the dark side without going dark. Force crush is a Dark side ability

  58. Politicians are weeds

    Politicians are weeds

    9 ditë më parë

    This is tough. I would give it to Luke because Anakin was overconfident in his 1st battle against Kenobi. As far as power, I would give it to Anakin if he reached his peak.

  59. NoMercyInc

    NoMercyInc

    9 ditë më parë

    nobody ever called luke prime

  60. AMLB Productions Music and Orchestration

    AMLB Productions Music and Orchestration

    9 ditë më parë

    I have a feeling unlike the Jedi under the council jaded by a war, Luke had to much compassion. Anakin would use that compassion against him. Its my personal opinion Anakin would come out on top. Plus I'm a sith at heart, so gotta root for Vader 🤣

    • A Tale’s Truth

      A Tale’s Truth

      8 ditë më parë

      Your assuming morals are on, in either case vader never wanted to kill luke nor luke with Anakin, if they fought it would never be to kill, and it just say disarming or beating them it’s still possible both will hold back regardless If morals are off and they have no knowledge of the other being father or son, luke won’t care what Anakin says or vis versa When it comes down to it they are equal if given the same experience and training, in which the fight comes down to circumstances or if one makes a mistake first in which if Anakin doesn’t humble himself is more likely then luke to make one,

  61. James Ellis

    James Ellis

    10 ditë më parë

    Anakin- I don't like sand luke- has sand in a little poutch and chucks it at him anakin- walks away crying

  62. Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

    Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

    10 ditë më parë

    Kylo vs Maul. I want to see in depth why Maul eviscerates Kylo

  63. ryan wolf

    ryan wolf

    10 ditë më parë

    Also though dad's will always spank their sons lol

  64. ryan wolf

    ryan wolf

    10 ditë më parë

    22 and 28 was a complete difference for me as a fighter 22 I would eat alot of unecessary shots trying to rope a dope then take them down after they were tired 28 I would touch them up and keep them on their back foot until they got desperate shoot on me and then submit them

  65. Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

    Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

    10 ditë më parë

    Luke wins. Luke beat Vader. Vader is literally just Anakin with 20+ more years of fighting experience and stronger than Anakin in the force. Vader when fighting Luke was in his prime, and Luke still won. And people say “oh Vader was conflicted and wasn’t trying”, which isn’t true since the ROTJ novelization says that Vader got angry and wanted Luke to know this fight wasn’t a joke, it was darkness, which implies that he starts trying against Luke. So Luke did beat Vader which obviously means that he can beat Anakin. And Luke and Anakin have the same force potential.

    • A Tale’s Truth

      A Tale’s Truth

      8 ditë më parë

      @Some Chinese guy for a profile picture you are correct about Anakin and Luke potential and your right in all anakins life being darth vader he has been more deadly then he ever has been as Anakin However think luke in episode 6 being on Anakin’s level in revenge of sith shouldn’t even be a question, do you think Luke can even beat obi won from revenge of the sith, by all reason you shouldn’t say no given Luke’s abilities aren’t even that of a knight as of yet and obi won is a master who has been for a decade even Anakin a knight could have beaten obi won given his youth and being just overall more lethal. Luke in mando when he has more years to actually master his abilities yes I think Luke could beat Vader and Anakin in a prime State, but episode 6 luke no

    • Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

      Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

      8 ditë më parë

      @A Tale’s Truth his prime, is the point he was most deadly, not a hypothetical “full potential” because if both Luke and Anakin were both in their full potential hypothetically, they’d be equals since they have equal potential

    • A Tale’s Truth

      A Tale’s Truth

      8 ditë më parë

      @Some Chinese guy for a profile picture vader was conflicted, not luke And Luke doesn’t know about who his father was before vader besides what obi won told him being not much

    • A Tale’s Truth

      A Tale’s Truth

      8 ditë më parë

      @Some Chinese guy for a profile picture no Anakin never reached his prime and vader is just a weaker version of what he could have been, Vader could never reach what he would have been if he never was defeated by obi won and that’s been stated many times, he was only better then His past self but would never reach his prime That’s the whole reason palpatine wanted to replace vader with luke because he could reach that level where his father can’t anymore Ps if vader was anakins full potential he would have been palptine already or palatine wouldn’t want someone to replace him in the first place

    • Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

      Some Chinese guy for a profile picture

      8 ditë më parë

      @A Tale’s Truth Vader knew Luke was conflicted, Anakin doesn’t, not to mention Luke likely knows Anakin was emotional

  66. maximilian melander

    maximilian melander

    10 ditë më parë

    luke has the second mush potential

  67. George Hopkins

    George Hopkins

    10 ditë më parë

    Anakin in revenge of the sith final fight would destroy Luke just cause of how fast he is also

  68. Mathew Flack

    Mathew Flack

    10 ditë më parë

    We really need a what if series made to where anakin reaches his full potential. I feel blue balled every time I see anakin being a beast and I just want to see him in his age from ROTJ but not in the suit and full mastery over the force itself and not just light or just dark sides.

  69. Jay Man

    Jay Man

    10 ditë më parë

    Yeah do Starkiller Vs

  70. Patrick R Pedrus

    Patrick R Pedrus

    10 ditë më parë

    Luke only has to take some sand out of his pouch, throw it at Ani and he'll lose 50 stamina for every ten grains.

  71. Lady Satine Kenobi

    Lady Satine Kenobi

    10 ditë më parë

    Sorry but Luke would lose To Anakin because he just wasn’t the swordsman that Anakin was .

  72. Stupid Idiot

    Stupid Idiot

    10 ditë më parë

    This isnt a fair comparison. Ur comparing 28 year old Luke to 22 year old anakin when he just unlocked his powers. If anakin has learned to control his powers by the time is 28, he would be 2x more powerful than Luke

  73. NoMonies1987

    NoMonies1987

    10 ditë më parë

    So I have always interpreted The Chosen One to be Luke. I have always figured that Luke was the one that brought balance to the force. I know Anakin "killed" Darth Sidious, but I have always believed that was only because of Luke. What are your thoughts on this? I'd like to hear what others think.

    • Darth Hollister

      Darth Hollister

      10 ditë më parë

      @NoMonies1987 it's not a matter of disagreement. Obi-Wan was just plain wrong. He said that because he thought that when Anakin fell to the Dark Side, it meant that Anakin wasn't the Chosen One anymore. In the OT Yoda and Obi-Wan were training Luke to KILL Vader, not to save Anakin. They both thought that Luke had to be the new Chosen One and destroy the Sith. They were wrong. George Lucas has literally stated multiple times that Anakin is the Chosen One, not Luke. And it doesn't even matter who is "supposed" to be the Chosen One cause when it comes down to it, if Anakin hadn't chosen to directly intervene and to kill Sidious, Luke would have died and balance would never have been restored. Anakin's choice was the direct cause of Balance being restored and the Sith being destroyed.

    • NoMonies1987

      NoMonies1987

      10 ditë më parë

      @Darth Hollister Respectfully, I disagree. There is the scene with Obi-Wan and Darth Maul on Tatooine in Rebels where Maul asks if the person Obi-Wan is protecting is the chosen one. Obi-Wan says he is, referring to Luke.

    • Darth Hollister

      Darth Hollister

      10 ditë më parë

      I mean a lot of people definitely think/used to think Luke was the Chosen One but it's literally canonical fact that Anakin is the Chosen One. It's not even a matter of interpretation. Luke was instrumental in helping Anakin fulfill his destiny but Luke's role is simply to restore balance within Anakin so that Anakin could then restore balance to the Force by killing Sidious.

  74. jjjjaeden

    jjjjaeden

    10 ditë më parë

    to all the ppl that said luke, i want what you’re smoking

  75. Attila Seyfullah

    Attila Seyfullah

    11 ditë më parë

    Force is more important than saber abilities so I agree.

  76. Will Dolliver

    Will Dolliver

    11 ditë më parë

    If this battle happened…I think Anakin would win because he would have had lightening as a Sith Lord later after ROTS and probbaley wouldn’t have the suit being more powerful as well.

  77. MrSaints74

    MrSaints74

    11 ditë më parë

    Without watching the video Legends Luke in his prime would have beat Anakin in his prime.

  78. The Parliamentarian

    The Parliamentarian

    11 ditë më parë

    Love you Theory, But albeit = all be it

  79. Chris G

    Chris G

    11 ditë më parë

    It’s hard to compare because let’s all be honest. The movies anakin was involved in were flashy and the saber duels doubly so. All the movies like was in the saber duels were more tradition sword fights. How can you honestly even compare the two.

  80. Peter Sarubbi

    Peter Sarubbi

    11 ditë më parë

    You grant Luke the rank of Master... But not Anakin? How can you do this? 😡 😂

  81. Austin Ed

    Austin Ed

    11 ditë më parë

    Anakin would win, but his destiny is to bring balance to the force because he is the chosen one. This is the way.

  82. MATHEW HAMILTON

    MATHEW HAMILTON

    11 ditë më parë

    Anakin’s strength from his robotic arm and the speed and quickness and fluidity combined I think would be too much for a guy just learning from old relic’s

    • Nate

      Nate

      9 ditë më parë

      Luke also has a robot hand

  83. Scott Addison

    Scott Addison

    11 ditë më parë

    TL:DW full power Anakin bodies Luke GF WP GG

  84. Rinnegan Itachi

    Rinnegan Itachi

    11 ditë më parë

    At that point in time Luke would probably defeat Anakin wich fought Obi Wan....but full potential Anakin vs full potential Luke would have been nice to see... i mean Legends Luke moved a blackhole with the force and thats probably not the limit of his power but then you have Mortis version of Anakin that forced the Son and the Daughter to theyre knees wich is harder than just killing them and still thats probably not his full potential... they would be like demi gods that would in time make Palpatine and Yoda look like boy scouts....if you can move blackholes you probably dont find the Death Star all that scary there would be nothin that the Galaxy could do to stop them all fleets armyes and superweapons useless

  85. jon doe

    jon doe

    11 ditë më parë

    The only reasons obi wan won his battle with anankin was he used a defensive form and aimed for attrition. that along with anakins bad judgment due to the him being enraged and 50 other head fuszing emotions came together to bring about anakins defeat. Obi wans victory/ survival was very circumstantial. I also dont believe their force pushes were on equal footing obi wan flew a lot further and anakin recovered a lot faster is you watch closely but you could argue thats arbitrary. As far as luke i hate to say this especially about luke but a saber duel with post geonosis, pre mustafar is almost ufair. In terms of the force i will admit they should be on equal footing if not luke having the slight advantage if we assume anakin isnt yet able to productively exploit his new sith powers. While anakins m count is a bit if an unknown quantity, lukes is said to some set amount higher than yodas, equal to leias and lower than his fathers but still in a close enough proximity to not be a huge hindrance in battle. If we then assume luke has had ample training since the last deathstar 5 years later with his potential the lack of restraint of the jedi order id put him pretty close to if not higher than anakin in force abilities depending on circumstances. If its the same fight as obi wan yes id give the advantage to luke. Anakin is in limbo between the light and the dark side and this is a major hindrance. If he is still with the light but post geonosis id give it anakin but if he was a full fledged sith it would be a completely unfair advantage for anakin . Now as for dueling this will be short like the fight would be anakin has an unprecedented unattainable unequivocal amount of experience in comparison to luke not only from the jedi temple but exploits with obi wan sith and all and his time during the clone wars which goes hand in hand with obi. Add into account his natural latent ability luke had close to the same potential as anakin but it is clearly seen how much more of a natural with a saber than luke granted luke was a natural pilot that isnt the discussion . Hope u liked my take cuz iT took forever ani for the win

  86. Alex Maurice

    Alex Maurice

    11 ditë më parë

    I feel real prime anakin was right before he turned to the dark side where he still had some darkness yet was mostly good still. Again luke is definitely smarter I feel like and more well rounded while I think when it comes to anakin he’s more strong and has more experience but I feel in only one way. They both had extremely strong wills so I think that part as well makes it such a hard choice

  87. Lukas D

    Lukas D

    11 ditë më parë

    What about Luke vs Count Dooku on the invisible hand

  88. Christian Bui

    Christian Bui

    11 ditë më parë

    Anakin is hardheaded, he is blinded by anger and can make any mistakes in the world during a fight while on the other hand Luke is calm and collective he uses his knowledge not his power alone.

    • DJ Heitland

      DJ Heitland

      11 ditë më parë

      He didn’t defeat Darth Vader by being calm and collected though. He had to almost go full on dark to win. Anakin is very capable at turning his anger into focus. He wiped out the Jedi temple and all of its masters there with ease, Including Battlemaster Cin Drallig. Giving this to Anakin. When he’s 100% on his game, there’s no one stronger. Obi Wan only won on Mustafar due to a insurmountable terrain advantage.

  89. prica1996

    prica1996

    12 ditë më parë

    Luke would vipe him from the face of the earth. Any time prime or not

  90. Fenrir8897

    Fenrir8897

    12 ditë më parë

    I think that is a reasonable conclusion. Anakin lacked the maturity and self-discipline to truly maximize his abilities. Luke would wait him out, stay calm, and when anakin either fatigued or screwed up, Luke would seize the opportunity and and pick him apart quickly and efficiently.

  91. Shagg420 gaming

    Shagg420 gaming

    12 ditë më parë

    Love this channel I’ve been here since before 500k

  92. dbooker34

    dbooker34

    12 ditë më parë

    What if burnt up, limbless, pre-suit Anakin fought just born a second ago Baby Luke? Who wins?...I've got Baby Luke

  93. ryan utley

    ryan utley

    12 ditë më parë

    I think Anakin would win. It’s like Thor fighting Odin. Where did he get his power from. His father

    • A Tale’s Truth

      A Tale’s Truth

      12 ditë më parë

      Well not really, Thor has been said that he could be stronger then his father, after all our legacy is supposed to better then us anyway, in all media of Star wars luke has Anakin’s potential in the forces so would Leia as well, the biggest difference is luke isn’t as trained as Anakin meaning at the same age given their cannon experiences Anakin would win, and in a hypothetical where both reach their primes assuming Anakin still in a arrogant mindset thinking he is still better and no one can beat him, luke would ironically beat him, because Luke used the light and darkness in harmony finding balance, being a true student and servant of the force being the more open minded fighter, while Anakin would be a blunt instrument only relaying on his raw power over control and skill, fighting to show dominance being aggressive, essentially it be comparing the father in his prime (aka luke in this instance) vs abeloth in her prime (Anakin in this instance) In other words both would relatively be equal, with a victor only arising due to the circumstances or mindsets of the fighters

  94. ドーカーアアーカード

    ドーカーアアーカード

    12 ditë më parë

    For someone who loves the prequels I agree with this Luke is more level headed than Anakin also this is prime Luke so I can see why he won But an issue is Luke can lose his level headed calmness by opponents like Vader and Palpatine who can mock his failures and torture him mentally making him go berserk but this is something that Anakin does not have like Vader does. Sure Clone Wars Anakin taunts his opponents at times but Nothing like Vader. So I agree on this verdict But I also can see Anakin winning this too if he sees someone he cares about hurt in front of him so yes Luke wins this but Anakin can also win too and assume they are both calm Now for a full potential Anakin vs Legends Luke??? Now I could be wrong about this but when GM Luke made his debut Lucas stated that Anakin's full potential is supposed to GM Luke but so much more

  95. AAC Goudie

    AAC Goudie

    12 ditë më parë

    Yeah, I've gotta see a max potential Anakin vs. Legends Luke! Legends Luke Skywalker might be one of the strongest beings in the galaxy

  96. Nick Mcdaniel

    Nick Mcdaniel

    12 ditë më parë

    Episode 3 Anakin would destroy episode 6 Luke easy

  97. Jacob Godofwar

    Jacob Godofwar

    12 ditë më parë

    I would say that ur right. my opinion that dark Vader or anakin strong and better than luke but he will all ways leave opening for Luke to get strike that he needs to win not saying luke is weak not at all he would one best Force user so yeah luke wins 100% also ur youtube channel is awsome.

  98. Monkey D. BoomE

    Monkey D. BoomE

    12 ditë më parë

    You keep mentioning Anakin's potential as the Chosen One. While powerful, it's more of a role that he had to fulfill, and less that no one can be as powerful as him. Unless something has changed recently, Luke has the same potential as Anakin. Yes, when Anakin taps into the Dark Side he gets a boost, as does anyone, but Luke being as balanced as he is in the Force will always beat a prime Anakin who never fully achieved his potential.

  99. hard sandwich

    hard sandwich

    12 ditë më parë

    Luke wins

  100. The Fireblaster

    The Fireblaster

    13 ditë më parë

    Please do that 100% on board with all this fantasy battle stuff gives you a different perspective to see what would’ve happened and I honestly think these what if’s give you a better side to what if something different happened with the outcome would’ve been would’ve been different or would’ve been the same that’s what’s so fascinating with these

Faqja Tjeter